James McDonald
Co-founder, Audience Group (Sydney)
James McDonald co-founded Audience Group, a Sydney media agency, after starting as a media planner at OMD. On The ADOTAT Show he said Google is marking its own homework on search, that frequency is a tax you pay for not being remembered, and that he plans brand campaigns around cost per day in memory.
Episode recorded Mar 13, 2025: Listen to the episodeRead the write-up
In their words, on The ADOTAT Show
4 quotes“They're marking their own homework. That's the main ripoff. You're trusting a platform to spend your money and tell you if it's working or not.”
James McDonald, On paid search, The ADOTAT Show, Mar 13, 2025
Context: Google calls him almost every week telling him to buy more. Read the write-up
“I liken search to putting an ad outside a supermarket on a poster saying, buy Campbell's soup. And then saying every can of soup within the supermarket that got bought was because of that ad.”
James McDonald, On search attribution, The ADOTAT Show, Mar 13, 2025
Context: He is not anti-search. He says it is massively overstated. Read the write-up
“The key to frequency is finding out when people start forgetting and then hit them again.”
James McDonald, On frequency, The ADOTAT Show, Mar 13, 2025
Context: Reach people once, wait for them to forget, then reach them again. Read the write-up
“That consumers make rational decisions.”
James McDonald, The biggest lie marketers tell themselves, The ADOTAT Show, Mar 13, 2025
Context: His first client had the cheapest mortgage rate in the market and still was not winning. Read the write-up
The episode and the story
The ADOTAT Show- Google Says Search Ads Drive Sales. Audience Group's James McDonald Says Google Is Marking Its Own Homework.
The full ADOTAT write-up of the interview, with the quotes in context.
- The ADOTAT Show with James McDonald
Listen to the full episode.
Quotes are from the recorded episode, trimmed for filler. Claims and figures are the guest's own unless the write-up says otherwise. Corrections to pesach@adotat.com.
Get the next one in your inbox
Free. Unsubscribe anytime.Read by the people who run the industry.
Investigations, executive interviews and the numbers the press releases leave out. Free in your inbox.